Dissertation Theses
Educational reform in Japan and Hong Kong: A comparative study of curriculum decentralization
- Educational reform in Japan and Hong Kong: A comparative study of curriculum decentralization
- 2004
-
- Hong Kong
- Japan
-
- 1997.7 onwards
-
- Primary Education
- Secondary Education
- This study is concerned with aspects of decentralization of curriculum development, a complex educational phenomenon, in Japan and Hong Kong. By introducing fieldwork and the case study research method, it hopes to yield a general understanding of the above phenomenon as reflected in the contexts of selected programs in curriculum reform, namely, (1) Project Learning and SBeD in Hong Kong, and (2) Integrated Learning in Japan, at junior levels of secondary school. In its research design, the objectives are to investigate and compare the broad trends and features in the rationale, practices and processes, and implications of reform in the locations studied. Trends of decentralization of curriculum development, in recent curriculum reforms in Japan and Hong Kong, indicated a strong policy interest in promoting specific essential skills and qualities through partial devolution of curricular control to schools. Most of these programs have multiple educational aims directed at either particular policy emphases or local school conditions, or both.
The practices and processes designed to bring about this change toward decentralization of curriculum development differed in the cases of Japan and Hong Kong. At the policy and system level, the levels of government involvement and commitment were not the same. Japan, through a combination of direct measures at the initiation stage and a longer-term policy of minimalist intervention, legitimized schools' autonomy over curriculum development decisions in the reformed programs, while Hong Kong, being traditionally less centralized and less effective with the power-coercive approach in curriculum planning, adopted more indirect strategies of exhortation and inducement while allowing schools full freedom over their own approach and priorities toward the specific reformed school curricula. In terms of school support systems, Japan seemed to be less prepared with the provision of practice guidelines, professional support and financial subsidies. Schools in Hong Kong were comparatively at some advantage in view of greater government involvement in supplying external information and resources. At the school level, practices tended to be diverse, though they generally reflected a propensity among schools to exploit, within permitted policy contexts, their autonomy over curricular objectives and content, teaching and organization of their reformed programs. In most cases, school's curricular interests focused on integrated skills and local issues with an emphasis on disengaging activities from academically-oriented learning (particularly, in Japan). Apart from time and material constraints, outcomes in my subject schools in the case study were affected by teachers' initiative, student quality, and presumably school leadership.
Fieldwork In the case study serves an exploratory function of providing hitherto unavailable information, particularly at the school level, about the implications and problems from the phenomenon in question. Further studies of a broader scope could be undertaken to assess such areas as effectiveness of implementation and support mechanisms, and the long-term development of the curriculum reforms. - MPhil
- University of Hong Kong
- Hong Kong
-
- English
- Dissertation Theses
- https://bibliography.lib.eduhk.hk/bibs/9ff0ff9f
- 2010-12-16
Recent Dissertation Theses
Development and implementation of a learning analytics tool to support teacher orchestration of collaborative science inquiry in a mobile learning environmentDissertation Theses
A qualitative study of the experiences of the parents in supporting their dyslexic children in secondary schoolsDissertation Theses
Evaluating the effectiveness of a self-developed financial education programme among primary school students in Hong KongDissertation Theses
有家長參與的幼兒生命教育課程: 以香港幼稚園的幼兒生命教育課程作個案研究Dissertation Theses
Curriculum intentions, classroom realities: The learning and teaching of English reading to Hong Kong secondary studentsDissertation Theses
融合小學視力障礙學生融合課程發展研究Dissertation Theses
Sing by ear: A study of motivation, informal learning, and musicianship of popular music education in Hong KongDissertation Theses
E-learning practices in preservice English language teacher education in Hong Kong and Mainland ChinaDissertation Theses